I believe this is very important interview. I am talking about the phantasmic nature of the the Jewish past, Shlomo Sand, the Exile, the Holocaust. Yet, one question remains open, why Jews face so many Shaos? I argue that Jewish historians always fail, they look onto particularities but turn blind eye to essentiality and the grand narrative. Time is ripe to deal with true meaning of Jewish identity politics. If Israel is the Jewish State, we must ask what this title entails.